The point is that if someone threatens you then don’t you have a right to defend yourself? In this case the six girls defended themselves in the wrong way and should pay the price. Victoria should never have made the comments on myspace. She should not have been bad mouthing a girl whose family gave her a place to live and she certainly should have never accepted a challenge to fight anyone else.
That article is contrary to what the Garcia woman and her mother said on Greta Van Susteren’s show the other night. On that program the grandmother said she had taken in the girl after she had a falling out with her parents. The mother said nothing about Lindsay living at the house as she walked Greta’s cameras through the crime scene. That also changes the earlier scenario you gave about her going to confront two girls. Interesting......
Still does not change the fact that she was held against her will and beaten unconscious and then beaten some more.
still 6 on 1 no matter what the motive.
Yeah i went to that website ... i read it… but i still dont see your point....
The only thing that needs to be said is, “ Do on to others as you would have them do onto you” If these kids would have learned that then maybe they would not have gotten together and beaten up anybody. Bad Parents all the way around.
http://www.heraldtribune.com/article/20080407/NEWS/804070448/1661
She wasn’t lured there. That was where she lived. Written threats
From my stand point it has nothing to do with pity for the victim. The victim could have been the nastiest kid in town with a mouth like a garbage dump, but she did not deserve this treatment.
I think she was lured to the location under false pretenses, held against her will and beaten. All of those things are against the law and considered criminal. Trash talk is only governed by civil law.
If the stories are true that she knew there would be a fight when she got there and she still went there then my answer is yes, she asked for it. Does it make the right thing to do for six girls or any number of girls to fight. My answer is no.
I could care less. If someone did that to me i wouldnt waste my time or go to jail over them. Kids will run their mouths its highschool. Ok so you are saying Lindsay asked for the beating?????? Give me a break. This beating was premeditated. That is absolutely Horrible ....
Oh my my! One teenage girl said something bad about another teenage girl!!!! That is just unheard of! Let’s get a rope and saddle up the horses.......