Boeing Dropping Out Of Tanker Battle?

By Reuters
.

Boeing is "strongly considering" not bidding on the $40 billion tanker contract. Some of its backers in Congress argue the revised terms of the competition, issued by the Pentagon last week, favor Northrop Grumman Corp and EADS. Boeing Dropping Out Of Tanker Battle?
Published: Mon, August 11, 2008 - 11:09 am
NEW YORK (Reuters) - Boeing Co is "strongly considering" not bidding on the upcoming competition for a $40 billion U.S. Air Force refueling tanker contract, Aviation Week, the aerospace industry magazine, reported on Monday, without identifying its sources.

The No. 2 Pentagon contractor has not commented on the issue publicly, but some of its backers in Congress have argued that the revised terms of the competition, issued by the Pentagon last week, favor Northrop Grumman Corp and its European partner EADS.

Boeing officials are "strongly considering the option of not submitting a proposal," according to the report on the magazine's website, citing "multiple sources familiar with Boeing's internal discussions."

Boeing declined comment on the report, saying that it had responded to the initial request for proposal and was set to meet Pentagon official on Tuesday to discuss it. Any decision on the competition before that would be "premature", said Boeing spokesman Dan Beck.

The company's shares were down 1.8 percent at $66.61 on the New York Stock Exchange.

The Pentagon last week reopened the tanker contract contest with a draft version of its requirements, and will spend the next week or so discussing the criteria with bidders. A final request for proposal is expected in mid-August, with a deadline of Oct. 1 for submission of bids.

The prospect of having only one bidder for the contract would be embarrassing for the Air Force and the Pentagon, which have gone out of their way to demonstrate that the competition is open and fair.

The Northrop/EADS team won the contest in February, but government auditors subsequently found errors in the way the competition was run. Prior to the competition, the Northrop/EADS team also vacillated about entering the competition, raising questions about fairness.

Last week, Boeing backers bristled at the terms and timetable of the Pentagon's new tanker competition.

The new criteria "appear to favor a tanker larger than any real-world scenarios would require", said Rep. Norm Dicks, a Washington state Democrat and Boeing backer last week, implying that it would favor the larger plane offered by Northrop/EADS.

Sen. Patty Murray, another Washington state Democrat, said the new documents raised some "red flags," and the timetable for new submissions was "simply unrealistic."

Boeing, which has traditionally built tankers for the U.S. Air Force, had a deal to supply a new fleet of tankers but the arrangement was scrapped in 2004 after it came to light that Boeing offered a job to a top Air Force procurement officer.

Translate: » Spanish | French | German | Italian | Japanese | Chinese | Russian | Hindi

Let’s don’t close the barn doors yet, We still don’t have all the horses corralled ! Carl Icann must be looking at the Boeing company and they’re getting a little antsy .

Report Abuse

They probably had this in mind along and thought that there cronies in Washington could get them a sweet deal and it didn’t work, so now they have no other option?  Waa-waa…

Report Abuse

Yeah, but if they drop out, aren’t they essentially retracting that complaint? Therefore, don’t they owe our military and the taxpayers the lost money of 6 months to date worth of delays?

Report Abuse

Boeing will probably figure out a way to get paid for their trouble.  In the GAO thing they said they felt Boeing should be reimbursed for the expense of filing the complaint, which sounded a little screwy to me.

Report Abuse

I wonder if Boeing refuses to re-bid, if the GAO can go back on them to make them compensate for all the problems they have caused over their temper tantrum? I fully agree we need to get on with the tanker, and I believe our tanker is the best. But I think Boeing should have to pay, if they don’t want to play, especially since they are the one’s who brought this to the battle grounds.

Report Abuse

It takes a lot of time and money to put together a bid on such a large project.  If the odds look bad, then dropping out might be the wise move.  Boeing has always wanted to push the 767 off on the AF as a tanker, but so far that is not happening.  The 777 still has a strong commercial life and does not really meet the needs of the AF.  The 787 does not even come close and any type of delivery schedule based on that aircraft would be very tentative.

Report Abuse

This would be the twilight zone if Boeing dropped out without more protesting.

Report Abuse

Let Boeing whine all it wants, but let’s get started with this tanker!  If Boeing drops out of the competition, the GAO should withdraw their objections to the original contract and let this show get on the road!!!!!!

Report Abuse

I’m not sure I would consider it embarrassing for the AF or Pentagon. I believe it just shows proof that the tanker they originally chose was the best and that Boeing CAN’T compete. I would expect the Boeing backers to continue to find something to whine about, and more reasons to cry foul play. Their statements here prove it.

Report Abuse

First reasonable thing I have heard out of Boeing since they first lost the fair & square competition!

Report Abuse

Recent Commented: News Reports

A Mother’s Pain 1-Year…

2 Total Comments
A Mother’s Pain 1-Year Later Time is not healing the wounds for the mother of the children… more »

Infant Dies From Shaken Baby…

1 Total Comments
Infant Dies From Shaken Baby Syndrome The 2-month-old's father is in jail charged with murder.… more »

Teen Performs Sex Act On Girl…

3 Total Comments
Teen Performs Sex Act On Girl In Class Police say the teacher had stepped out for 10 minutes. Other… more »

Second Arrest In Thanksgiving…

2 Total Comments
Second Arrest In Thanksgiving Day Murder Police have arrested a second man for the murder of Edward… more »

‘Missing’ Cop Stole…

1 Total Comments
‘Missing’ Cop Stole $70,000 In Drug Money Sgt. Faron White is now accused of taking $70,000 from a… more »

Judge Issues Arrest Warrant…

3 Total Comments
Judge Issues Arrest Warrant For Sheriff The Alabama sheriff was held in contempt of court for failing… more »

 


Contact Information   •   Internships   •   Open Ratings   •   Advertise With Us
FCC-EEO Report   •   Children's Programming   •   Public File