That was a big surprise when Johns got the boot. Not as big as the year Chris Daughtry got kicked off though. I think every one's jaw hit the floor on that one.
I missed that jaw dropper. I didn't start watching until late season 2006(the last couple of shows). Now I hate that I missed all those seasons, and I'll never miss it again, if I can help it.
I just watched the video of Brooke and Castro on the Idol website and I liked them both. That kind of music is tough and not made for all musicians, but I thought they were both good. Syesha screams a little too much for my taste, but this was probably one of her better performances.
Who's performing tonight? Anyone? I would hate to see Brooke go, she is such a sweetie. But I think the competition will ultimately come down to David Cook and David Archuletta. Carly may be in the final 3, but I don't see her being an Idol winner, simply because I don't know about her overall appeal. Something about all those tatoos on her and her husband doesn't shout "role model" to me. But she does have a nice voice. David Cook and David A. are my fav's.
I was on the edge of my seat the entire hour. But they all gotta go sometime. I'll miss Carly next week, but once again, it's hard to call anything absolute. I think the two Davids are going to go all the way, (and I hope I don't curse them by saying so, it seems everytime I call it, they get booted) but I am rooting for David Cook for the win. Once again, they are all very talented, so however it goes it won't be disappointing.
